Why is it called a white elephant? The history of the name

The real history behind “white elephant”: sacred elephants in Southeast Asia, a legend historians doubt, Barnum’s 1884 elephant and how a phrase became a game.

By Imogen Vale · · 5 min read

A white elephant holding a wrapped gift between two palace arches, for the history of the name white elephant

IN SHORT

  • Pale elephants were rare and prized by the courts of Burma, Siam and their neighbors. They were kept in style and not put to work.
  • The famous story of a king ruining courtiers with the gift of a white elephant is a legend. Word historians have found no record of it happening.
  • In English, “white elephant” has meant a costly thing nobody wants since at least 1851. The gift exchange borrowed the name later.
In this article

Every December, people who have never seen an elephant bring a wrapped candle to a party named after one. The name has a real history, a popular legend that probably is not true, and a showman who made the phrase famous in America. Here is what can be said with confidence, and what cannot.

The real elephants

In the kingdoms of mainland Southeast Asia, including Burma (now Myanmar) and Siam (now Thailand), unusually pale elephants were rare and were tied to royal power. A king who owned one was thought to be favored, and the animals were kept at court with attendants and ceremony. They were not used for hauling timber or carrying loads as ordinary elephants were. An animal that eats like an elephant and does no work is expensive to own, and that plain fact sits under everything that followed.

The legend of the ruinous gift

The story most people know goes like this: a king of Siam who wanted to punish a courtier would give him a white elephant. The courtier could not refuse a royal gift, could not put a sacred animal to work, and was slowly ruined by the cost of keeping it.

It is a good story. Researchers who have gone looking for it in the record have not found a documented case of a Thai king doing this, and several word historians treat it as a later embellishment that grew up around the phrase. The Wordorigins site has a careful account of the evidence. So the honest version is that the tale is widely told and unproven.

The phrase in English

English writers mentioned white elephants as real animals from the sixteenth century. The meaning we use now, a possession that costs more than it is worth, shows up in the middle of the nineteenth century. The earliest example usually cited is a letter written in 1851 by the English novelist Geraldine Jewsbury, who compared a man’s unhelpful services to “so many white elephants, of which nobody can make use.” Her letters were not published until 1892, so she was using a figure of speech that was already around, not inventing one. By the later 1800s the phrase was ordinary English for an expensive burden.

Barnum’s white elephant

In 1884 the American showman P. T. Barnum brought an elephant called Toung Taloung from Burma to New York and advertised it as a sacred white elephant. Audiences expecting a snow-white animal saw an elephant that was pale and pinkish in patches. A rival showman, Adam Forepaugh, answered with a “white” elephant of his own, which accounts from the time say had simply been whitened. The newspapers enjoyed the fight, and the Public Domain Review has the whole episode. It helped fix “white elephant” in American speech as a name for something that fails to live up to its cost.

From a phrase to a sale to a party

Once the phrase meant an unwanted possession, it attached itself to the places where such things change hands. Churches and clubs held white elephant sales, where members donated things they no longer wanted and somebody else carried them home. A gift exchange built on the same idea, bring something and leave with something else, was a short step from there.

Exactly when the stealing game began is not known. A researcher who writes about the history of popular phrases has found a description of a “swap party” from 1901 that looks a lot like the modern game. You will often read that Ezra Cornell, the founder of Cornell University, started the tradition in 1828. That claim is repeated widely and none of the accounts point to a source, so it is best treated as folklore.

One game, three names

In much of the United States the game is a white elephant. In New England it is often a Yankee swap, and across the South a Dirty Santa. The rules are the same family of rules under each name, with house variations, and the differences are set out in white elephant, Yankee swap and Dirty Santa.

What the name means at a party today

The original white elephant was a gift you could not use and could not give away. The modern game keeps the joke and fixes the problem: if you open something you do not want, somebody may steal it, and if you see something you do want, you may steal that. Most groups now set a dollar limit and bring gifts worth having, with a few gag gifts for the laugh.

If you would like to play one, White Elephant Live runs the game in a browser for groups in one room or spread across the country, and the rules page has the common rules in plain language.

Questions people ask

Did kings of Siam really give white elephants as a punishment?+
There is no documented case. Pale elephants really were prized and expensive to keep, but the story of a king ruining a courtier with one appears to be a legend that grew up around the phrase.
When did “white elephant” start to mean an unwanted gift?+
The sense of a costly, unwanted possession is found in English from the middle of the nineteenth century. The earliest example usually cited is a letter from 1851.
Is a white elephant gift supposed to be bad?+
Originally the joke was an unwanted item. Today most groups set a price limit and bring gifts people would be glad to take home, sometimes with a few gag gifts mixed in.

White Elephant Live is the online white elephant gift exchange for families, friends and teams. The host sets up a party in two minutes, guests join with a code from any phone or laptop, and the game keeps the turn order, counts the steals and lists who ended up with what. See how it works, read the white elephant rules, or play the free demo.

Keep reading

Ready to host?

Two minutes to set up, from $69 for the whole party. Guests join with a code, no accounts, and never pay.