White elephant vs. Secret Santa: which gift exchange fits your group?

White elephant and Secret Santa solve different problems. A side-by-side comparison of rules, cost, effort and which one suits families, friends and offices.

By Wes Abernathy · · 4 min read

A pile of white elephant gifts with steal arrows on the left and one Secret Santa gift with a name tag on the right

IN SHORT

  • Secret Santa is a personal gift for one named person. White elephant is a game where nobody knows who will take a gift home.
  • Choose Secret Santa when people know each other well. Choose white elephant when they do not, or when you want the exchange to be the entertainment.
  • White elephant is easier on the organizer: nobody has to draw names or keep secrets.
In this article

Both are ways for a group to exchange gifts without everyone buying for everyone. They feel very different on the day. One is a quiet, thoughtful swap. The other is a game with winners, groans and at least one gift that half the room wants.

The short version

White elephantSecret Santa
Who you buy forNobody in particularOne named person
What happensPlayers take turns opening or stealing giftsEach person opens a gift chosen for them
Kind of giftSomething anyone would enjoy, or a gagSomething personal
SetupSet a price limitDraw names in secret, then set a limit
EntertainmentHigh: the game is the partyLow: gifts are opened and thanked
Time on the dayTwo to three minutes per playerA few minutes in total
Works when people barely know each otherYesNot well

How Secret Santa works

Before the party, every participant is secretly assigned one other person. You buy a gift for that person within the limit, and at the party the gifts are handed out. In some groups the givers are revealed and in others they stay secret.

Its strength is that every gift is chosen for someone. Its weakness is the same thing: you have to know the person. In an office where you drew someone from another floor, that turns into a generic candle and mild worry.

How white elephant works

Everyone brings one wrapped gift and nobody is assigned anyone. Players draw a turn order. On your turn you open a wrapped gift or steal one that has already been opened. A person who is stolen from chooses again. Most groups lock a gift after three steals so the game can end. The full rules are on the white elephant rules page.

Its strength is that the exchange itself is the fun, and nobody needs to know anybody. Its weakness is that you might go home with something you did not want, which is, historically, the whole joke behind the name.

Which one for which group

Families

Secret Santa suits a family that wants fewer, better presents. White elephant suits a family gathering with cousins, partners and new faces, where a game gets three generations laughing at the same thing.

Friends

Either works. White elephant is the better choice when the group includes people who are meeting for the first time.

Offices and teams

White elephant is usually the safer option at work. Nobody has to guess what a colleague they hardly know might like, and nobody opens a gift that says more about what the giver thinks of them than either person wanted. It also fills a party slot: the game is the activity.

Remote groups

Secret Santa by post works with no meeting at all, which is useful across many time zones. A virtual white elephant needs everyone on a call at once and gives them something to do together. Pick by whether the goal is a gift or an hour of shared fun.

What each one costs

The spending per person is the same: one gift at the limit. The difference is in effort. Secret Santa needs someone to run a secret draw, handle the person who drew themselves and chase the person who forgot. White elephant needs a limit, a date and a way to keep track of steals.

Mixing the two

  • Secret Santa with a steal round. Open the personal gifts, then let anyone who wishes put theirs into a short white elephant.
  • White elephant with a theme. A theme gives the gifts some of the thoughtfulness of Secret Santa. There are fifteen in white elephant themes.

If the answer for your group is white elephant, White Elephant Live keeps the turn order, counts the steals and lists who ended up with what, in the room or on a call. There is a free demo to see a full game first.

Questions people ask

Is white elephant the same as Secret Santa?+
No. In Secret Santa you buy for one assigned person. In white elephant nobody is assigned, and gifts are chosen and stolen in a game.
Which is better for an office party, white elephant or Secret Santa?+
White elephant suits most offices better, because nobody has to choose a personal gift for a colleague they do not know well and the game doubles as the party activity.

White Elephant Live is the online white elephant gift exchange for families, friends and teams. The host sets up a party in two minutes, guests join with a code from any phone or laptop, and the game keeps the turn order, counts the steals and lists who ended up with what. See how it works, read the white elephant rules, or play the free demo.

Keep reading

Ready to host?

Two minutes to set up, from $69 for the whole party. Guests join with a code, no accounts, and never pay.