White elephant, Yankee swap, Dirty Santa: what’s the difference?

Three names for one gift-stealing game. What each name usually implies, the house rules that really change the game and which version to choose.

By Wes Abernathy · · 2 min read

Updated

Three wrapped gifts with tags for white elephant, Yankee swap and Dirty Santa

IN SHORT

  • They are the same game. The name mostly tells you where the host grew up.
  • What changes the experience is the steal limit, and whether the first player gets a final swap.
  • Ask for the house rules before the first turn, whatever the game is called.
In this article

They are the same game with regional accents. “White elephant” is the common name in most of the United States, and it tends to suggest gag gifts. “Yankee swap” is the New England name, often with nicer gifts. “Dirty Santa” is heard across the South, and the name promises that stealing is the point.

None of the three has an official rulebook. What you are really being invited to is one family’s or one office’s version, so the name matters less than the house rules.

What each name usually implies

NameWhere you hear itUsual flavor
White elephantMost of the United StatesGag gifts or a mix, with a modest limit
Yankee swapNew EnglandUseful gifts people want
Dirty SantaThe SouthGood gifts and plenty of stealing

These are tendencies, not rules. A Yankee swap in one town can be identical to a Dirty Santa in another.

The rules that change the game

  • The steal limit. With unlimited steals, a popular gift can circle the room and the game can drag. Most groups lock a gift after its third steal.
  • Stealing back. Nearly every version says you cannot take back the gift that was just taken from you in the same turn.
  • Steals per turn. Some groups end a turn after three steals in a row, so one gift cannot swallow the evening.
  • The first player. Going first means opening blind with nothing to steal. Many versions give player 1 a swap at the end to make up for it.
  • What a stolen-from player may do. In most versions they choose again: open a new gift or steal a different one.

Which version to choose

For a group that has not played together before, the three-steal lock with a final swap is the easiest to explain and always ends. It is the version White Elephant Live enforces: a gift can be stolen once per turn and three times in the game, three steals in a row end the turn, and the first player gets a final swap. The complete list is on the rules page.

Curious where the elephant comes from? The name has a longer story than the game, told in why it is called a white elephant.

Questions people ask

Is Yankee swap the same as white elephant?+
Yes, it is the same game under a New England name. Individual hosts differ on steal limits and the final swap, so check the house rules.
Why is it called Dirty Santa?+
The name points at the stealing: taking a gift from another player is the “dirty” part. It is the usual name for the game in much of the American South.

White Elephant Live is the online white elephant gift exchange for families, friends and teams. The host sets up a party in two minutes, guests join with a code from any phone or laptop, and the game keeps the turn order, counts the steals and lists who ended up with what. See how it works, read the white elephant rules, or play the free demo.

Keep reading

Ready to host?

Two minutes to set up, from $69 for the whole party. Guests join with a code, no accounts, and never pay.