White elephant strategy: when to steal and when to open

The steal limit changes everything. A turn-by-turn guide to white elephant strategy: what to do early, what to do late and how to end up with a locked gift you want.

By Theo Lindqvist · · 4 min read

Three white elephant gifts with arrows showing steals between players and a padlock on the locked gift

IN SHORT

  • The third steal locks a gift. If you want something, try to be the third person to steal it.
  • A wrapped box is a gamble and an opened gift is a sure thing. Steal when you see something you would take home.
  • Going late is an advantage, and going first is not as bad as it looks when the game has a final swap.
In this article

White elephant is mostly luck and a little judgment. The judgment matters more than people expect, because of one rule: a gift can only be stolen a set number of times. Everything below assumes the common rules, which are also the ones White Elephant Live uses. A gift can be stolen once per turn and three times in the game, and then it is locked with whoever holds it. The first player gets a swap at the end.

Count the steals

The most useful habit is to track how many times each good gift has been stolen.

Steals so farWhat it meansIf you want it
0Fresh. It can change hands three more times.Taking it now makes you a target. Wait if you can.
1Still two steals from locking.Risky. You will probably lose it.
2One steal from locking.Take it. Your steal is the third, and it is yours for good.
3Locked.Gone. Look elsewhere.

The whole strategy is in that third row. The player who makes the third steal keeps the gift. If you hold something with two steals on it, expect to lose it. If you see something with two steals on it and it is your move, it is the safest gift in the room.

Early in the game

  • Open, mostly. There is little to steal, and anything you steal now has many turns left to be taken from you.
  • Do not get attached. A great gift opened on turn two will almost certainly move.
  • Watch what the room wants. The gifts people groan about losing are the ones that will lock early.

In the middle

  • Steal the gift with two steals on it if you would be glad to keep it.
  • Being stolen from is a free move. You get to choose again, with more information than you had on your own turn.
  • Open a wrapped gift when everything good is locked or fresh. A wrapped box nobody has seen cannot have steals on it, and the room may not want it.

Late in the game

  • You have the best seat. Most gifts are open, several are locked, and few players are left to steal from you.
  • Take the best unlocked gift. With few turns left, even a gift with one steal on it is likely to stay.
  • The last wrapped box is a wild card. Whoever is stolen from near the end may have to open it.

If you are player 1

The first player opens a gift with nothing to compare it to and nothing to steal. To make up for it, most rule sets give player 1 a final swap after every gift is open: they may trade what they hold for any gift that is not locked. With a final swap, going first means choosing from the whole table at the end, minus the locked gifts. Without one, it is the worst seat. If you are hosting, include the swap.

Three quiet tactics

  1. Hold your gift with a straight face. People steal what others seem to love.
  2. Sell the gift you do not want. Admiring it out loud is fair play.
  3. Remember the once-per-turn rule. A gift that was just stolen cannot be stolen again in the same turn, so the person who took yours is safe until the next number is called.

New to the game? The rules page has the full list, and the free demo lets you play a round against practice players to try all of this.

Questions people ask

Is it better to go first or last in white elephant?+
Last, in most games, because you see every opened gift before you choose. First is good only when the rules give the first player a final swap.
Should you steal or open in white elephant?+
Steal when an opened gift is something you would take home, especially if it has already been stolen twice, because your steal locks it. Otherwise open.
Can you steal a gift back?+
Not right away. Under the common rules you cannot take back a gift in the same turn it was taken from you. You can steal it on a later turn if it is not locked.

White Elephant Live is the online white elephant gift exchange for families, friends and teams. The host sets up a party in two minutes, guests join with a code from any phone or laptop, and the game keeps the turn order, counts the steals and lists who ended up with what. See how it works, read the white elephant rules, or play the free demo.

Keep reading

Ready to host?

Two minutes to set up, from $69 for the whole party. Guests join with a code, no accounts, and never pay.